I think we'd each have our own personal hut tailored to our interests/personalities:
eddo - would of course open up his Mammogram/Gynocology Hut...because he cares about us wimmins.
snafu - his Fishing Hut would be filled with handmade tackle and fishing gear. He'll let you use it, but you have to tweak his nipples first.
Old Salt - he'd find clever and creative ways to turn coconut milk and hibiscus flowers into a nectar for the gods. His Drinking Hut would be the most popular one of all!
Cloaked - he'd have a Spanking Hut. I'd probably spend a lot of time there, cuz I'm kind of kinky like that.
Bender - he would be kind enough to feed us all at his Food Hut. His shrimp and seaweed culinary delights would be the talk of the island.
TJ - would host Manipulators Anonymous meetings at his Quilt Hut.
wez - when you stop at wez's I'm Not You Hut, you would learn who you are and that you, in fact, are NOT wez.
hugo - he'd sit daily outside of his Idle Rich Hut and yell "get a job, you **** commie!" at us when we walk by.
IWS - he would have the To Protect and to Serve Hut, where he would protect his right to be served.....orally.
RO - he'd find a way to fashion thumbtacks out of raw materials he found on the island. He'd also decorate his Thumbtack Hut with roughly hewn "Hang in There!" posters he makes out of sticks, rocks, snot, sand, shells, and other questionable bodily fluids.
Merc - would have an I'd Rather Be In Georgia Hut and she'd make homemade bumper stickers with that slogan....even though none of us have a car.
emkay - her Canadian Healthcare Hut would be free of charge for us all and she'd laugh maniacally when she would make TJ wait for months on end for his ingrown toenail surgery.
Chi - she'd be the sole proprietor of The Donkey Show Hut. Oddly enough, there would be no donkey....or show.
Anna Perenna - would own the Scrabble Hut, where wez would be a permanent fixture.
Me - my Doritos Hut would be robbed constantly. It would suck.