G
Gandalf Grey
Guest
UN Peacekeeping Paramilitarism
By Stephen Lendman
Created Feb 15 2007 - 8:20am
The world community calls them "Blue Helmets" or "peacekeepers," and the UN
defines their mission as "a way to help countries torn by conflict create
conditions for sustainable peace" by implementing and monitoring
post-conflict peace processes former combatants have agreed to under
provisions of the UN Charter. The Charter empowers the Security Council to
take collective action to maintain international peace and security that
includes authorizing peacekeeping operations provided a host country agrees
to have them under Rules of Engagement developed and approved by all
parties. At that point, the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations enlists
member nations to provide force contingents to be deployed once the Security
Council gives final approval.
Once in place, Blue Helmets are supposed to help in various ways including
monitoring the withdrawal of combatants, building confidence, enforcing
power-sharing agreements, providing electoral support, aiding
reconstruction, upholding the rule of law, maintaining order, and helping
efforts toward economic and social development. Above all, "peacekeeping"
missions are supposed to be benevolent interventions. They're sent to
conflict areas to restore order, maintain peace and security and provide for
the needs of people during a transitional period until a local government
takes over on its own.
Far too often, however, things don't turn out that way, and Blue Helmets end
up either creating more conflict than its resolution or being
counterproductive or ineffective. In the first instance, peacekeepers become
paramilitary enforcers for an outside authority. In the second, they do more
harm than good because they've done nothing to ameliorate conditions or
improve the situation on the ground and end up more a hindrance than a help.
This article focuses mostly on the former using Haiti as the primary case
study example after reviewing peacekeeping operations briefly in six other
countries. In each case, the examples chosen show people on the ground as
helpless victims of imperial exploitation (usually US-directed) with UN Blue
Helmets used by outside powers for social control and domination, not
keeping the peace.
First, a brief account of other failed "peacekeeping" missions is reviewed
after an overview of the UN, its founding purpose and how the US dominates
and undermines the world body for its own interests.
The UN - Its Founding Purpose and Mission
The UN was established in 1945 after WW II when 50 original member countries
signed its Charter in San Francisco. Today 192 nations are member states.
Its founding Charter states its purpose and mandate is: "to save succeeding
generations from the scourge of war....reaffirm faith in fundamental human
rights....(support) equal rights of men and women....of nations large and
small....establish conditions under which justice....can be
maintained....promote social progress....practice tolerance and live in
peace (and promote) economic and social advancement of all peoples." From
its founding date till now, the world body failed on all counts even though
some of its agencies (like UNICEF, WFP, UNHCR and UNESCO) have a history of
providing important services in areas of health, education, food assistance,
aiding refugees, social development and more.
Nonetheless, the UN is hamstrung by a serious obstacle. Its dominant member
is the US that undermines the world body's authority and effectiveness for
its own imperial interests. It does it through its Security Council veto
power, by withholding dues, disengaging from UN activities or just muscling
or bribing member states to get its way. It gets away with it by being the
world's leading economic, political and military superpower beholden to no
interests but its own. It takes full advantage, and for over half a century
used the UN as its foreign policy instrument or rendered it ineffective by
inaction or obstruction. If allowed to be a voice for all member states, the
UN could be a powerful one for global democratic governance and promotion of
social equity and equal justice. Instead one dominant nation's veto power
trumped the will of all others causing a shameful history of UN failure and
ineffectiveness. As long as a single nation's monkey wrench can jam its
works, the UN will never fulfill its founding purpose.
It's apparent in its Charter-mandated peacekeeping role. If the UN
functioned as a neutral international body pursuing its founding mission, it
would always act to establish and maintain peace in every conflict area. It
doesn't because its dominant member won't let it. So it failed to act when
Indonesia invaded East Timor in 1975 slaughtering hundreds of thousands in a
secretly US-authorized aggression including the arming and supporting of
Indonesian military TNI forces. It stood by again after the East Timorese
voted by referendum for independence in 1999 after which TNI forces attacked
and slaughtered thousands more.
The UN did nothing during South Africa's border wars and invasion of Namibia
in the 1960s and 70s and allowed a 36 year civil war to go on in Guatemala
following the CIA fomented coup in 1954 ousting the country's democratically
elected leader Jacobo Arbenz Guzman. It ignored a succession of oppressive
military and civilian governments still ruling the country. It allowed them
to compile the hemisphere's worst human rights record even after the UN
brokered a Peace Accord formally ending the civil conflict mainly against
the country's indigenous Mayan majority slaughtering 200,000 of them. It
still ignores the government's shameless human rights abuses in a country
Amnesty International calls a "land of injustice." But it happens to be one
the US considers a close ally, and that's all that counts as Washington has
the final say on most everything at the UN.
These are a few of the many examples of UN failures to address injustice
throughout the world on every continent. It belies discredited former UN
Secretary-General Kofi Annan's standing up for the Security Council claiming
it has primary responsibility for maintaining international peace and
security. It can't even prevent human rights abuses because it's mostly a
talking shop, and the world body overall is a wholly owned subsidiary of the
nation where its headquartered. It uses it to pursue its imperial agenda
knowing no nation will dare try stopping it most often. And when the threat
arises, Washington ignores it to do what it pleases like attacking Iraq
without required Security Council approval and threatening now to extend the
conflict to Iran on blatantly false cooked up charges that smell as bad as
the WMD ones about its occupied neighbor.
UN Peacekeeping Operations
UN peacekeeping operations began in 1948 with its first one ever UNTSO
mission to monitor the Arab-Israeli first of two brief failed truces in
Israel's "War of Independence" beginning in June, 1948. The operation is
still ongoing, peace was never achieved, the UN plays no active role, and
UNTSO wastes money and takes up space observing and reporting what it wishes
selectively while Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) have total control of
everything on the ground. UNTSO ineffectiveness shows in the way the IDF
continues repressing and assaulting defenseless Palestinians while the UN
gets out of their way functioning as little more than worthless window
dressing. In 2006 it had a meager staff of 371 military and civilian
observers and a budget of $30 million, all of which could have been better
spent elsewhere on a real mission for a real purpose if there are any.
That inauspicious start was symbolic of what lay ahead in 61 total
peacekeeping missions undertaken to date ignoring all the other conflicts it
should have intervened in but didn't. Currently 16 missions are ongoing as
of year end 2006 plus two other small special political and/or peacebuilding
ones with 113 countries contributing 99,817 military troops, observers,
police and civilians budgeted for the 12 months through June, 2007 at $4.75
billion under names like UNIFIL in Lebanon created in 1978 for the same
purpose it's still there for and now enlarged following Israel's withdrawal
from the country last summer after its horrific invasion and assault weeks
earlier.
UNIFIL Blue Helmets in Lebanon
Israel attacked and invaded Lebanon last July 12 following Hezbollah's
cross-border incursion that was used as a pretext to ignite pre-planned
aggression against the country and its people. The result was mass killing,
crippling destruction, and a huge refugee problem all without Israel
achieving its planned aim - to destroy Hezbollah resistance in South
Lebanon. It proved too much for the world's fifth most powerful military
equipped with state-of-the-art weaponry courtesy of the most powerful
Washington-based one.
UNIFIL was established to restore and maintain peace in South Lebanon one
week after Israel's invasion of the country in March, 1978. It's been there
since including throughout the period from 1982 when Israel again invaded
and remained until withdrawing its forces in May, 2000. Despite its mandate,
UNIFIL never established peace and security and did little more than take up
space allowing the IDF free reign to control everything on the ground along
with its proxy Christian South Lebanon Army acting as paramilitary enforcer
thugs of a largely Shia Muslim population.
"Proxy" describes UNIFIL's current role in Lebanon that has little to do
with keeping peace and everything to do with being NATO's Israel enforcer.
In that role, it can engage Hezbollah in confrontation if it chooses and do
Israel's fighting and dying for it. It also represents a continuation of
nearly three decades of "peacekeeping" failure in South Lebanon. The current
one won't work any better than all efforts preceding it because UNIFIL is
beholden to Israel, the US and NATO and will follow their mandate having
nothing to do with peace and stability and everything to do with imperial
control and dominance. The people of South Lebanon know all about UNIFIL's
"benefits," but you won't hear them say thank you.
UNAMIR in Rwanda
UNAMIR was set up to help implement the Arusha Accords in 1993 to ease
tensions, secure the capital, and monitor a ceasefire and security agreement
prior to the outbreak of ethnic slaughter that began after CIA
surface-to-air missiles shot down the aircraft carrying Rwandan President
Juvenal Habyarimana and Burundi President Cyprien Ntaryamira in April, 1994.
That "unfortunate" plane accident made way for US-trained Rwandan Patriotic
Army (RPA) Major-General Paul Kagame to take power so Washington could use
the country as a base to pursue its greater prize in resource-rich Congo
(DRC). It didn't matter that hundreds of thousands died and millions in
Congo where war subsided, but instability remains because warring sides and
Western interests still contest for control of the country's immense
resources.
Canadian General Romeo Dallaire led a UN 400 troop contingent in Rwanda, got
no additional force help, mostly stood aside as thousands were slaughtered,
and was only authorized to act in self-defense meaning his orders were do
nothing. He left the country in August, 1994 followed by the departure of
his replacements when UNAMIR's mandate ended in 1996 long after the damage
was done. The result - a dismal mission failure in UN peacekeeping with
hundreds of thousands dead because Blue Helmets were told to ignore it.
UNIMIK in Kosovo
UNMIK was created in 1999 for war-torn Kosovo as an interim civilian
administration to remain in place until the Serbian province's fate is
decided. Its stated mission includes maintaining the rule of law, protecting
human rights, coordinating humanitarian and disaster relief, supporting
reconstruction efforts, and assuring refugees and displaced persons can
return to their homes. As always, stated goals are noble, but results
shameful - another mission failure staying longer will just exacerbate, not
ameliorate.
The mission language hides the grim history of the 1990s Balkan wars. They
destroyed a nation making its new pieces easy pickings for US and Western
imperial exploitation and control. It had nothing to do with removing a "bad
guy" Serbian leader and everything to do with installing new leadership more
responsive to Western interests - meaning unconditional surrender to
imperial authority. The US-led 1999 NATO assault was called an humanitarian
intervention. It's real aim was to finish breaking one nation into six more
easily handled ones plus deciding the fate of Serbia's Kosovo province to be
dealt with later.
In Kosovo, Washington and NATO collaborated with Kosovo Liberation Army
(KLA) paramilitary thugs ignoring their connection to organized crime. They
got free reign to commit terrorist attacks including ethnic cleansing of
Serbs and other minorities in the province. The US-led war caused massive
population displacement, not the other way around as news reports claimed.
Nor did the war bring Kosovo peace and stability. Far from it. The province
is part of Serbia, and Serbs want to keep it that way. But it looks like
they won't as Albanians in the majority have other ideas with assurance
their US ally will help them.
After the war, the former Serbian province got semi-autonomy as a UN
protectorate with its final status nearly decided by the world body
intending to make Kosovo semi-independent because the US wants it that way.
It doesn't matter what Serbs want for territory they're about to lose. The
scheme was unveiled on January 26 to the six-member contact group of major
powers including the US, UK, France, Germany, Italy and Russia all of whom
approve except Russia that remains skeptical enough to try to scuttle the
plan. It supports Serbia that rejects the deal but has little power to stop
it unless Russia vetoes it in the Security Council with final say on the
matter.
That verdict isn't in yet, but some things are clear. Whatever Kosovo's
nominal disposition, Serbs will be losers and US and Western imperial
control will continue by virtue of a proxy repressive UNIMIK/NATO Blue
Helmet contingent remaining in place for an indefinite time likely to be
lengthy. It's how imperial management works. People lose out so hegemons can
win, and when it involves the US the price paid is big and painful.
MONUC in the Democratic Republic of Congo
MONUC began its operations in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) in
1999 and is the largest peacekeeping force now in place but one hardly
adequate (if it mattered) for a country the size of Western Europe. MONUC
was authorized to monitor a ceasefire agreement between waring sides as well
as be involved in the usual kinds of things peacekeeping entails. After
years of unresolved conflict, few places anywhere need peace and stability
more than DRC in the wake of the country's long-running war taking 4 million
or more lives causing immeasurable human misery and harm.
All along, the UN was inept, counterproductive and out of the loop. It was
more part of the problem than its solution. It knew all about legal and
illegal arms trading fueling conflict but didn't stop it because its
controlling members did the selling like they always do in war zones
everywhere. In addition, Blue Helmets weren't where most needed and didn't
help when able because direct orders said not to. Kofi Annan was part of the
problem as he was as UN head of peacekeeping in 1994 allowing Rwandans to be
slaughtered when his efforts at least might have ameliorated conditions.
Instead, he kept his mouth shut and head down, refusing to act as he later
did as Secretary-General serving imperial interests he was beholden to. That
meant ignoring desperate people in Congo and all other warring regions.
The DRC is a major one even though things are mostly quieted down - for now.
The country's cursed by being the likely most resource-rich piece of real
estate in the world (except for not having large oil reserves). That makes
it a key target for imperial exploitation and control with Congo's people
suffering just by being there. Sending Blue Helmets to keep peace is just a
fig leaf hiding the dark side of the conflict and who stands to gain with US
interests always topping the list and acting as guarantor nothing interferes
with what Washington has in mind.
So all parties ignore the situation on the ground, and Blue Helmets just
make it worse. The evidence shows UN forces engaged in sex trafficking,
using children as prostitutes. They abused young girls and got away with it
because MONUC officials took no preventive action in spite of pious claims
decrying it. What's common in Congo happens everywhere with so-called
"peacekeepers" acting as thuggish enforcers for imperial powers. Their
mission is "keeping the rabble in line" with free reign to do it harshly as
long as it's kept under wraps. What happens in Congo goes on in Kosovo,
Liberia, Sudan (discussed below) and Haiti also discussed in detail shortly.
It's an ugly story of crackdown, repression or indifference hidden under the
cover of "peacekeeping."
UNMIS in Sudan
UNMIS was established in 2005 to implement the January, 2005 Comprehensive
Peace Treaty between the Sudanese government and Sudan People's Liberation
Movement/Army. It ended the protracted North-South 22 year civil war killing
and uprooting millions in one of the continent's most costly wars, but not
freeing the nation from conflict still ongoing in Darfur. UNMIS has
authority to administer there once hostilities subside, waring sides allow
them entry and agree to cooperate, and Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir
decides if he's willing to risk a regional occupying force hostile to his
interests. Currently a 7,000 force African Union Mission in Sudan (AMIS)
operates in Darfur that's pathetically slim for an area the size of France
in a country the size of Western Europe.
The Sudanese government is justifiably reluctant for Blue Helmets to come
knowing how they behave elsewhere. It also knows what fuels the conflict and
what interests the US and West in the area. Like most everywhere, it's about
valuable resources, and in Darfur it's mainly oil as it is in Somalia where
Washington is involved in another proxy war with US supportive air and
ground involvement this time using an Ethiopian force to be supplemented or
replaced by other regional country contingent "peacekeepers."
The Darfur conflict is falsely portrayed in Western media reports as
atrocities committed by Arab Jan jawid militias supported by the Khartoum
government against black African people. The truth is all parties involved
are indigenous Arabic-speaking black Sunni Muslims involved in intertribal
fighting over increasingly scare water and grazing rights in an area hard
hit by draught and famine. If Blue Helmets come in, they'll make things
worse because they'll be sent for imperial control further harming the
people enduring more than they can already handle.
MINUSTAH in Haiti - Our Main Focus
Since European settlers first arrived in Haiti 500 years ago, this nation
experienced an almost unparalleled legacy of colonial violence and
exploitation. Even when the country gained freedom from France on January 1,
1804, it lay in ruins. Its plantations and sugar works were burned and large
parts of its cities were rubble from many years of conflict. It cost the
nation half its population of former slaves on top of its indigenous
population nearly exterminated by Spanish Conquistadors beginning with the
arrival of Columbus.
Things got no better when Spain kept the Eastern two-thirds of the island in
what's now the Dominican Republic leaving the Western third for French
colonization beginning in the early 1600s. France brought over black African
slaves controlling it till after the 1789 French Revolution that inspired
Haitians to wage theirs for the same freedoms French people got briefly. Led
by Toussaint L'Overture, they prevailed establishing the first free
independent black republic anywhere on their New Years liberation day in
1804.
It was short-lived as France regained control holding it till America took
over later solidifying its regional lock when Woodrow Wilson sent in Marines
in 1915 to protect US investments, doing it in typical US fashion - at the
barrel of a gun. Nineteen years of brutal exploitation followed with
massacres like the kinds seen in Haiti today. The worst of them was in 1929
when US Marines slaughtered 264 protesting peasants in Les Cayes. There were
also smaller incursions, forced labor, and aerial bombing years before the
Nazis' infamous attack on Spain's Republican government at Guernica
supporting opposition fascist dictator, Francisco Franco.
Except for a decade of relief under Jean-Bertand Aristide and Rene Preval,
nothing improved for Haitians after US occupiers left in 1934. Aristide and
Preval brought hope in spite of great Western constraint imposed on them. It
didn't last courtesy of US Marines again ending a brief grace period of
relief and deliverance for people having precious little of it for 500
years.
In its wake, MINUSTAH was established by UN Security Council vote on April
30, 2004 two months after the US-led coup ousted President Aristide now in
forced exile in South Africa. From inception, it's mission was flawed as it
had no right being there in the first place. Blue Helmets, in principle, are
deployed for peace and stability even though they seldom bring it. In this
case, peacekeepers have may been illegally sent for the first time ever
supporting and enforcing a coup d'etat against a democratically elected
president instead of staying out of it or coming to back his right to
office.
The US runs everything in Haiti, and MINUSTAH became its repressive arm
against Haitian people wanting their President back and their freedoms under
him restored. The result is no surprise. MINUSTAH's mission is disastrous,
disgraceful and in violation of the rule of law including UN's own Charter
as explained below.
Before it began, the UN lied claiming Aristide was less than democratically
reelected in 2000 with under 10% of Haitians participating. UN officials
further implied his Fanmi Lavalas party manipulated results allowing him to
win. The truth was otherwise showing Aristide won with a 92% majority and a
turnout of around 62% of eligible voters or a figure exceeding that in most
US elections. The International Foundation for Election Systems (IFES)
suggested turnout was even higher, but mainstream reporting never lets facts
conflict with official US government versions of truth that hide it when it
isn't the kind it wants.
The line on Haiti came from the US State Department's affiliated Agency for
International Development (USAID) claiming the opposition boycotted the
election and Aristide won by default with a low voter turnout. This got
reported as anti-Aristide black propaganda contradicting mass-Haitian
support for a beloved leader twice elected the country's President. Haitians
demand his return but won't get it as long as the US remains in charge.
Washington will ignite a firestorm if he tries coming setting off the kind
of ugliness leading to what happened in February, 2004 that repeated similar
events in September, 1991 after Aristide's first election. The result for
Haitians is nightmarish courtesy of the Bush administration with complicit
Security Council support in the form of Blue Helmet "peacekeepers" enforcing
their kind of peace.
They're on the ground along with mobilized death squads, otherwise known as
the hated Haitian National Police (PNH), acting as a main duel proxy force
serving their masters in Washington. They've done it by destroying all
democratic freedoms in a country subjugated for 500 years under outside
authority or one imposed on them from within. In 1990, Haitians hoped it
ended when they elected Jean-Bertrand Aristide President with 67% of the
vote. He took office in February, 1991, but his tenure was short-lived. It
ended in September by the first of two US-instigated coups removing him from
office for a more compliant military ruler beholden to Washington and its
capital interests.
Aristide returned to Haiti in 1994 regaining nominal power through a deal
Clinton officials arranged. It included a largely US-led UN peacekeeping
force remaining until 1999 to assure political and economic continuity by
IMF-imposed neoliberal structural adjustment policy diktats of
privatizations, debt serving and cuts in vitally needed social services.
Under these conditions and with little financial support when he tried going
around them, Aristide governed like a social democrat compiling an
impressive record given the constraints on him. Under Haitian law, he was
unable to succeed himself in 1996, but his ally Rene Preval ran for
President and won with an 88% majority. Aristide then ran again in 2000
winning big as explained above.
>From then until 2004, Aristide instituted a host of important programs in
>areas of health, education, justice and human rights. He did it by
>maneuvering around the kinds of harsh dictates imposed on him out of
>Washington. It led to his second ouster reinstituting a US-directed reign
>of terror with MINUSTAH Blue Helmet proxies in the lead implementing harsh
>repression still ongoing and unaddressed by a world community mindful of
>conditions but turning a blind eye or playing a supportive role. Blue
>Helmets do this everywhere, but it gets no worse than in Haiti. It's the
>poorest country in the hemisphere, conditions continue getting worse,
>people are suffering, and MINUSTAH is there to keep it that way, not bring
>peace, security, stability or freedom to people desperately needing it.
It's all about the rules of imperial management Washington forces on all
nations but especially ones with strategically important resources, markets
or in the case of Haiti cheap labor. Haiti has lots of it, and it's some of
the cheapest in the world. It's an offshore US manufacturer's paradise where
many garment and other workers earn as little as 12 cents an hour or
near-slave wages. It's far below the poverty level even in Haiti, and after
transportation and other expenses an average Haitian worker earns around $6
a week for those able to get any work in a country plagued by high
unemployment running as high as 50% and at times much higher. During his
tenure, President Aristide alleviated this and much more in spite of great
constraints on him. He did it with scant outside help in spite of
overwhelming pressures from Washington not to do anything affecting capital
interests.
With him gone and reelected President Rene Preval hamstrung under foreign
occupation masquerading as "peacekeepers," Haitians have lost everything.
Conditions have never been worse, and it goes on daily in Haiti's
bloodstained streets patrolled by MINUSTAH, PNH and militarized gangs of
enforcers with license to kill and brutalize freely. The Western media
ignore it in a country the US controls as a de facto colony using violence
for social control just like in Iraq with its own and proxy Iraqi forces.
Guatemalan UN Special Envoy Edmond Mulet calls it needing to "liberate"
neighborhoods from "thugs, criminals, gangs (and) drug dealers." He
characterizes indiscriminate killing of unarmed civilians as "collateral
damage" with UN forces coming "under attack (from gangs in Cite Soleil)."
What he won't address is MINUSTAH'S role as enforcer to make Haiti safe for
predatory capitalism with harsh repression the method of choice to do it.
It's aim is to destroy all vestiges of democratic Lavalas and Jean-Bertrand
Aristide's influence, but it resulted in mass-people resistance on the
streets protesting their plight and demanding restitution of their rights as
free people. Their answer is armed attacks and regular assaults.
It goes on daily with punishing effects against helpless people. They're led
by Blue Helmet thugs attacking Haitians in impoverished areas like Cite
Soleil, Bel Air, Solino and elsewhere indiscriminately killing men, women
and children. They work with PNH enforcers incarcerating or murdering
Aristide supporters and advocates for freedom and justice, forcing many
others underground or to flee the country even after Aristide's Fanmi
Lavalas party was effectively destroyed.
Before Preval's reelection last February, MINUSTAH helped reinstitute
Haiti's brutal and hated former military that Aristide disbanded and put
Haiti again at the mercy of predatory international lending agencies. It
also worked with the so-called Interim Government of Haiti (IGH) under
US-installed puppet prime minister Gerard Latortue ending Aristide's social
programs and returning the country to capital interests with lots of infused
cash ending up in the pockets of the interim government Transparency
International (TI) called the most corrupt in the world, but not enough to
bother its US boss looking the other way and ignoring it. The IGH even
locked up dissenters and emptied prisons of real criminals for service in
the PNH. It also reconstituted Haiti's military and allowed private
paramilitary gangs to operate as brutish enforcers of their own defenseless
people.
It's gone on since the 2004 coup in splendid fashion through bloody street
crackdowns including massacres against people protesting their plight in a
country returned to serfdom under repressive overlords. Haiti is short on
law, order, justice and freedom and long on paramilitary thuggishness
keeping things that way including the private paramilitary ones like the
Little Machete Army that was implicated in the July 6, 2006 Grand Ravine
massacre of more than 20 people along with burning scores of houses in an
act of pure savagery. It was after the August 21, 2005 slaughter in a Grand
Ravine soccer field in front of 5000 fans when as many as 50 people were
shot or hacked to death with machetes by PNH thugs and red-shirted killers.
A recent horrific incident happened in the early morning hours of December
22, 2006 in Cite Soleil when UN Blue Helmets assaulted the community killing
more than 30 people with some reports claiming much higher numbers. It
happened in random mass shooting striking people everywhere including in
their homes with bullets easily penetrating paper-thin walls. The UN claimed
it was after a young man named Belony, supposedly the head of a kidnapping
gang, but the story is pure "baloney" like all other MINUSTAH ones. It's
UN's way to justify repression and killings saying it's targeting bandits
that are really ordinary Haitians protesting their misery or who happen to
be in the line of fire that's deliberately indiscriminate as an added form
of terror.
Disturbingly, President Rene Preval apparently approved the December 22
operation and now has blood on his hands to answer for. He likely knew it's
purpose was to punish an impoverished community that put 10,000 people on
the streets a few days earlier demonstrating for the return of Jean-Bertrand
Aristide and condemning a US-directed militarized occupation of their
country. Video footage and eye witnesses captured and verified the
retaliatory response on the streets with unarmed civilians shot by random
gunfire including from helicopter gunships. At first the UN denied it but
finally admitted what video footage and digital photos showed conclusively.
They also showed wounded and dying with no medical help on the scene and
people left to bleed to death on the streets or in their homes.
This assault was like an earlier one against Cite Soleil on July 6, 2005
when UN forces attacked the city with hundreds of heavily armed troops using
M-50s and 60s mounted on armored personnel vehicles. It also used
high-powered telescopic rifles for accuracy in singling out targeted
dissenters for assassination and a type of gattling gun firing
armor-piercing bullets believed to be depleted uranium tipped to slice
through metal like butter. This time about 70 people were shot
indiscriminately from thousands of rounds of ammunition fired. Again those
hit were left to bleed to death unattended on the streets or in their homes.
A more recent documented incident happened in Cite Soleil on January 23,
2007 with MINUSTAH forces again randomly shooting for hours including from
helicopters while people ran for their lives or were gunned down
indiscriminately as they did. No accurate count of casualties is known so
far, and the number killed may never be known as Blue Helmets often remove
bodies to conceal the extent of their handiwork. Another attack followed on
January 24 with MINUSTAH acknowledging it killed six people and wounded
others in the same targeted community. Haitians won't ever be free of this
until peacekeepers leave, Blue Helmet terrorism ends and people can choose
their own leaders, free from outside control, or not live under ones imposed
on them.
For now, that seems light years away, and all reports out of Haiti are grim
including a January 23 one by the National Bishops' Justice and Peace
Commission (JILAP), a human rights commission of Haiti's Roman Catholic
church. It reported at least 539 people died violently in Port-au-Prince
alone in the three month period ending December 31, 2006 with the true
number likely higher as it only counted dead bodies on the streets. Most of
the victims were in impoverished communities like Cite Soleil, Grand Ravine,
Martissant and Bolosse, and the main cause of death was from gunshot wounds.
JILAP also attributed most of the violence to MINUSTAH and PNH with most
deaths just local residents in targeted areas. Other violence was blamed on
street gangs like the one led by the Little Machete Army that may have
murdered Haitian independent journalist Jean Remy Badiau in Martissant
because he "dared practice journalism in a country where the press (today)
is never free."
Sadly, Haitians have no freedom because the extent of occupation-led terror
is greater than Haiti's ever had in its 200 year history as a sovereign
state. It amounts to collective punishment of an impoverished people living
under US-imposed police state type daily killings, massacres, rapes,
arbitrary arrests, mass incarcerations, beatings and horrific immiseration
of millions of people defenseless against it. It also includes human
trafficking of women and children for forced prostitution and men and women
for forced labor amounting to chattel slavery. Additional thousands of men
have been forcibly taken to the Dominican Republic and other regional
countries to work for wages so low they're called "sugar slaves."
Still more abuse came out in the September, 2006 Lancet reported study
conducted by Wayne State University, School of Social Work researchers
Athena Kolbe and Dr. Royce Hutson. They exposed and documented massive human
rights violations in Haiti under the puppet Latortue government using random
Global Positioning System (GPS) coordinate sampling of 1260 households and
5720 individuals. 90.7% of them were interviewed using a structured
questionnaire by trained interviewers to learn about their experiences since
Aristide's ouster.
The study findings estimated 8,000 people were murdered and about 35,000
women (over half under 18)sexually assaulted in the greater Port-au-Prince
area between February, 2004 and December, 2005. 21% of killings were
attributed to the PNH, 13% to the demobilized army and another 13% to
anti-Aristide paramilitary gangs like the Little Machete Army. Known
criminals were the worst sex offenders, but officers from the HNP accounted
for 13.8% of assaults and armed anti-Lavalas groups another 10.6%. The
report also documented kidnappings, extrajudicial detentions, physical
assaults other than rape, death threats, physical threats and threats of
sexual violence against helpless people.
The report concluded that "crime and systematic abuse of human rights were
common in Port-au-Prince" involving criminals but also "political actors and
UN (Blue Helmet) soldiers." It also stressed an overwhelming need on the
ground for attention to "legal, medical, psychological, and economic
consequences of widespread human rights abuses and crime."
The study ended in December, 2005, but the same abuses go on daily in
Haitian communities around Port-au-Prince and elsewhere in the country. It's
a picture of UN failure and its top officials and Secretary-General
corrupted and criminally complicit with its authorized missions' worst
crimes and abuses going on everywhere. It also shows the world body as a
servant of power, defiling its founding mandate and damning the poor and
weak to pay for its failure to protect them. Nowhere are things worse than
in Haiti, and nowhere are UN representatives more culpable starting at the
top where the buck stops with its former Secretary-General Kofi Annan. His
tenure ended in December as it began - in disgrace but whose record went
unreported because he served power interests well who'll now reward him in
his new endeavors.
Haitians hoped things might not be this way last February 7 when they
reelected Rene Preval their President in an electoral process orchestrated,
controlled and rigged by the US-installed puppet government but not enough
to override the will of the people. For the first time in two years,
desperate Haitians had reason to celebrate with a leader again in charge who
once served their needs as President. But nothing is ever simple in Haiti,
and long knives in Washington were out to undermine and destabilize Preval's
rule from its outset or simply work around him and ignore it. The result to
date is capital rules the country, and Rene Preval has little to show for
his first year in office. Haitians continue suffering, and 9,000 repressive
Blue Helmets, PNH and other paramilitaries are on the ground keeping it that
way.
It affects the lives of helpless people in ways beyond brute force and
economic depravation. Blue Helmet attacks in Cite Soleil severely damaged
the community's public water system as random gunfire hit pipelines and a
water tower. It forced area residents to walk long distances with heavy
buckets for what's unavailable close by while private speculators truck in
drinking water for sale at prices Cite Soleil's half million residents can't
afford. It's one more part of marketplace rule leaving most Haitians out of
it with no resources to participate.
The UN peacekeeping mandate expires on February 15, but Haitians won't see
the end of it. The Security Council is about to extend the mission with
disagreement over its length that comes up for review every six months.
Before leaving office, Kofi Annan recommended a year's extension, but
unanimity hasn't yet been reached by Security Council members. When it is,
it won't reflect the peoples' will demanding Blue Helmets leave that's
loudly heard on the streets and ignored as it always is.
Protests and demonstrations are on the capital's streets all the time, but a
major one happened on February 7 as well as in six other Haitian cities and
many around the world in solidarity. They dramatically dispelled the UN's
false assertions that Lavalas is dead. It lives, it's vibrant, and it puts a
lie to UN Envoy Edmond Mulet's claim that "the issue of former President
Aristide is not present anymore....in Haiti....and his (Fanmi Lavalas)
movement is very much divided, weakened."
The date marked the 16th anniversary of Jean-Bertrand Aristide's first
inauguration as Haiti's first elected President in 1991 and 21st anniversary
of the end of the hated Duvalier father-son dictatorship in 1986. Tens of
thousands of Fanmi Lavalas supporters took to the streets peacefully to
protest their occupation and violence from it. They called for the release
of all political prisoners and demanded return of those in forced exile
starting with their former President deposed on February 29, 2004.
Protestors joined with them in solidarity in 53 cities around the world on
five continents against Blue Helmet massacres in an "International Day in
Solidarity with the Haitian People." On the same day, protesters went to
Haiti's UN heavily guarded Port-au-Prince military headquarters demanding
Aristide's return and confronting soldiers with shouts of "Down with the
UN." Hundreds were back the following day repeating their chants and risking
the kind of retaliation they've come to expect before.
They got their answer on February 9 when hundreds of UN peacekeepers again
raided Cite Soleil before dawn continuing their ritualized crackdown and
retaliation against courageous people resistance. It's made Blue Helmets a
hated symbol of imperial repression and all the terror from it. For Haitian
people, it's just the latest chapter in their 500 year struggle never losing
hope one day they'll be free at last. No people deserve it more than do
Haitians.
Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at
lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net [1].
Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com [2] and tune in online to
hear The Steve Lendman News and Information Hour on TheMicroEffect.com [3]
each Saturday at noon US central time.
_______
--
NOTICE: This post contains copyrighted material the use of which has not
always been authorized by the copyright owner. I am making such material
available to advance understanding of
political, human rights, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues. I
believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material as
provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107
"A little patience and we shall see the reign of witches pass over, their
spells dissolve, and the people recovering their true sight, restore their
government to its true principles. It is true that in the meantime we are
suffering deeply in spirit,
and incurring the horrors of a war and long oppressions of enormous public
debt. But if the game runs sometimes against us at home we must have
patience till luck turns, and then we shall have an opportunity of winning
back the principles we have lost, for this is a game where principles are at
stake."
-Thomas Jefferson
By Stephen Lendman
Created Feb 15 2007 - 8:20am
The world community calls them "Blue Helmets" or "peacekeepers," and the UN
defines their mission as "a way to help countries torn by conflict create
conditions for sustainable peace" by implementing and monitoring
post-conflict peace processes former combatants have agreed to under
provisions of the UN Charter. The Charter empowers the Security Council to
take collective action to maintain international peace and security that
includes authorizing peacekeeping operations provided a host country agrees
to have them under Rules of Engagement developed and approved by all
parties. At that point, the UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations enlists
member nations to provide force contingents to be deployed once the Security
Council gives final approval.
Once in place, Blue Helmets are supposed to help in various ways including
monitoring the withdrawal of combatants, building confidence, enforcing
power-sharing agreements, providing electoral support, aiding
reconstruction, upholding the rule of law, maintaining order, and helping
efforts toward economic and social development. Above all, "peacekeeping"
missions are supposed to be benevolent interventions. They're sent to
conflict areas to restore order, maintain peace and security and provide for
the needs of people during a transitional period until a local government
takes over on its own.
Far too often, however, things don't turn out that way, and Blue Helmets end
up either creating more conflict than its resolution or being
counterproductive or ineffective. In the first instance, peacekeepers become
paramilitary enforcers for an outside authority. In the second, they do more
harm than good because they've done nothing to ameliorate conditions or
improve the situation on the ground and end up more a hindrance than a help.
This article focuses mostly on the former using Haiti as the primary case
study example after reviewing peacekeeping operations briefly in six other
countries. In each case, the examples chosen show people on the ground as
helpless victims of imperial exploitation (usually US-directed) with UN Blue
Helmets used by outside powers for social control and domination, not
keeping the peace.
First, a brief account of other failed "peacekeeping" missions is reviewed
after an overview of the UN, its founding purpose and how the US dominates
and undermines the world body for its own interests.
The UN - Its Founding Purpose and Mission
The UN was established in 1945 after WW II when 50 original member countries
signed its Charter in San Francisco. Today 192 nations are member states.
Its founding Charter states its purpose and mandate is: "to save succeeding
generations from the scourge of war....reaffirm faith in fundamental human
rights....(support) equal rights of men and women....of nations large and
small....establish conditions under which justice....can be
maintained....promote social progress....practice tolerance and live in
peace (and promote) economic and social advancement of all peoples." From
its founding date till now, the world body failed on all counts even though
some of its agencies (like UNICEF, WFP, UNHCR and UNESCO) have a history of
providing important services in areas of health, education, food assistance,
aiding refugees, social development and more.
Nonetheless, the UN is hamstrung by a serious obstacle. Its dominant member
is the US that undermines the world body's authority and effectiveness for
its own imperial interests. It does it through its Security Council veto
power, by withholding dues, disengaging from UN activities or just muscling
or bribing member states to get its way. It gets away with it by being the
world's leading economic, political and military superpower beholden to no
interests but its own. It takes full advantage, and for over half a century
used the UN as its foreign policy instrument or rendered it ineffective by
inaction or obstruction. If allowed to be a voice for all member states, the
UN could be a powerful one for global democratic governance and promotion of
social equity and equal justice. Instead one dominant nation's veto power
trumped the will of all others causing a shameful history of UN failure and
ineffectiveness. As long as a single nation's monkey wrench can jam its
works, the UN will never fulfill its founding purpose.
It's apparent in its Charter-mandated peacekeeping role. If the UN
functioned as a neutral international body pursuing its founding mission, it
would always act to establish and maintain peace in every conflict area. It
doesn't because its dominant member won't let it. So it failed to act when
Indonesia invaded East Timor in 1975 slaughtering hundreds of thousands in a
secretly US-authorized aggression including the arming and supporting of
Indonesian military TNI forces. It stood by again after the East Timorese
voted by referendum for independence in 1999 after which TNI forces attacked
and slaughtered thousands more.
The UN did nothing during South Africa's border wars and invasion of Namibia
in the 1960s and 70s and allowed a 36 year civil war to go on in Guatemala
following the CIA fomented coup in 1954 ousting the country's democratically
elected leader Jacobo Arbenz Guzman. It ignored a succession of oppressive
military and civilian governments still ruling the country. It allowed them
to compile the hemisphere's worst human rights record even after the UN
brokered a Peace Accord formally ending the civil conflict mainly against
the country's indigenous Mayan majority slaughtering 200,000 of them. It
still ignores the government's shameless human rights abuses in a country
Amnesty International calls a "land of injustice." But it happens to be one
the US considers a close ally, and that's all that counts as Washington has
the final say on most everything at the UN.
These are a few of the many examples of UN failures to address injustice
throughout the world on every continent. It belies discredited former UN
Secretary-General Kofi Annan's standing up for the Security Council claiming
it has primary responsibility for maintaining international peace and
security. It can't even prevent human rights abuses because it's mostly a
talking shop, and the world body overall is a wholly owned subsidiary of the
nation where its headquartered. It uses it to pursue its imperial agenda
knowing no nation will dare try stopping it most often. And when the threat
arises, Washington ignores it to do what it pleases like attacking Iraq
without required Security Council approval and threatening now to extend the
conflict to Iran on blatantly false cooked up charges that smell as bad as
the WMD ones about its occupied neighbor.
UN Peacekeeping Operations
UN peacekeeping operations began in 1948 with its first one ever UNTSO
mission to monitor the Arab-Israeli first of two brief failed truces in
Israel's "War of Independence" beginning in June, 1948. The operation is
still ongoing, peace was never achieved, the UN plays no active role, and
UNTSO wastes money and takes up space observing and reporting what it wishes
selectively while Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) have total control of
everything on the ground. UNTSO ineffectiveness shows in the way the IDF
continues repressing and assaulting defenseless Palestinians while the UN
gets out of their way functioning as little more than worthless window
dressing. In 2006 it had a meager staff of 371 military and civilian
observers and a budget of $30 million, all of which could have been better
spent elsewhere on a real mission for a real purpose if there are any.
That inauspicious start was symbolic of what lay ahead in 61 total
peacekeeping missions undertaken to date ignoring all the other conflicts it
should have intervened in but didn't. Currently 16 missions are ongoing as
of year end 2006 plus two other small special political and/or peacebuilding
ones with 113 countries contributing 99,817 military troops, observers,
police and civilians budgeted for the 12 months through June, 2007 at $4.75
billion under names like UNIFIL in Lebanon created in 1978 for the same
purpose it's still there for and now enlarged following Israel's withdrawal
from the country last summer after its horrific invasion and assault weeks
earlier.
UNIFIL Blue Helmets in Lebanon
Israel attacked and invaded Lebanon last July 12 following Hezbollah's
cross-border incursion that was used as a pretext to ignite pre-planned
aggression against the country and its people. The result was mass killing,
crippling destruction, and a huge refugee problem all without Israel
achieving its planned aim - to destroy Hezbollah resistance in South
Lebanon. It proved too much for the world's fifth most powerful military
equipped with state-of-the-art weaponry courtesy of the most powerful
Washington-based one.
UNIFIL was established to restore and maintain peace in South Lebanon one
week after Israel's invasion of the country in March, 1978. It's been there
since including throughout the period from 1982 when Israel again invaded
and remained until withdrawing its forces in May, 2000. Despite its mandate,
UNIFIL never established peace and security and did little more than take up
space allowing the IDF free reign to control everything on the ground along
with its proxy Christian South Lebanon Army acting as paramilitary enforcer
thugs of a largely Shia Muslim population.
"Proxy" describes UNIFIL's current role in Lebanon that has little to do
with keeping peace and everything to do with being NATO's Israel enforcer.
In that role, it can engage Hezbollah in confrontation if it chooses and do
Israel's fighting and dying for it. It also represents a continuation of
nearly three decades of "peacekeeping" failure in South Lebanon. The current
one won't work any better than all efforts preceding it because UNIFIL is
beholden to Israel, the US and NATO and will follow their mandate having
nothing to do with peace and stability and everything to do with imperial
control and dominance. The people of South Lebanon know all about UNIFIL's
"benefits," but you won't hear them say thank you.
UNAMIR in Rwanda
UNAMIR was set up to help implement the Arusha Accords in 1993 to ease
tensions, secure the capital, and monitor a ceasefire and security agreement
prior to the outbreak of ethnic slaughter that began after CIA
surface-to-air missiles shot down the aircraft carrying Rwandan President
Juvenal Habyarimana and Burundi President Cyprien Ntaryamira in April, 1994.
That "unfortunate" plane accident made way for US-trained Rwandan Patriotic
Army (RPA) Major-General Paul Kagame to take power so Washington could use
the country as a base to pursue its greater prize in resource-rich Congo
(DRC). It didn't matter that hundreds of thousands died and millions in
Congo where war subsided, but instability remains because warring sides and
Western interests still contest for control of the country's immense
resources.
Canadian General Romeo Dallaire led a UN 400 troop contingent in Rwanda, got
no additional force help, mostly stood aside as thousands were slaughtered,
and was only authorized to act in self-defense meaning his orders were do
nothing. He left the country in August, 1994 followed by the departure of
his replacements when UNAMIR's mandate ended in 1996 long after the damage
was done. The result - a dismal mission failure in UN peacekeeping with
hundreds of thousands dead because Blue Helmets were told to ignore it.
UNIMIK in Kosovo
UNMIK was created in 1999 for war-torn Kosovo as an interim civilian
administration to remain in place until the Serbian province's fate is
decided. Its stated mission includes maintaining the rule of law, protecting
human rights, coordinating humanitarian and disaster relief, supporting
reconstruction efforts, and assuring refugees and displaced persons can
return to their homes. As always, stated goals are noble, but results
shameful - another mission failure staying longer will just exacerbate, not
ameliorate.
The mission language hides the grim history of the 1990s Balkan wars. They
destroyed a nation making its new pieces easy pickings for US and Western
imperial exploitation and control. It had nothing to do with removing a "bad
guy" Serbian leader and everything to do with installing new leadership more
responsive to Western interests - meaning unconditional surrender to
imperial authority. The US-led 1999 NATO assault was called an humanitarian
intervention. It's real aim was to finish breaking one nation into six more
easily handled ones plus deciding the fate of Serbia's Kosovo province to be
dealt with later.
In Kosovo, Washington and NATO collaborated with Kosovo Liberation Army
(KLA) paramilitary thugs ignoring their connection to organized crime. They
got free reign to commit terrorist attacks including ethnic cleansing of
Serbs and other minorities in the province. The US-led war caused massive
population displacement, not the other way around as news reports claimed.
Nor did the war bring Kosovo peace and stability. Far from it. The province
is part of Serbia, and Serbs want to keep it that way. But it looks like
they won't as Albanians in the majority have other ideas with assurance
their US ally will help them.
After the war, the former Serbian province got semi-autonomy as a UN
protectorate with its final status nearly decided by the world body
intending to make Kosovo semi-independent because the US wants it that way.
It doesn't matter what Serbs want for territory they're about to lose. The
scheme was unveiled on January 26 to the six-member contact group of major
powers including the US, UK, France, Germany, Italy and Russia all of whom
approve except Russia that remains skeptical enough to try to scuttle the
plan. It supports Serbia that rejects the deal but has little power to stop
it unless Russia vetoes it in the Security Council with final say on the
matter.
That verdict isn't in yet, but some things are clear. Whatever Kosovo's
nominal disposition, Serbs will be losers and US and Western imperial
control will continue by virtue of a proxy repressive UNIMIK/NATO Blue
Helmet contingent remaining in place for an indefinite time likely to be
lengthy. It's how imperial management works. People lose out so hegemons can
win, and when it involves the US the price paid is big and painful.
MONUC in the Democratic Republic of Congo
MONUC began its operations in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) in
1999 and is the largest peacekeeping force now in place but one hardly
adequate (if it mattered) for a country the size of Western Europe. MONUC
was authorized to monitor a ceasefire agreement between waring sides as well
as be involved in the usual kinds of things peacekeeping entails. After
years of unresolved conflict, few places anywhere need peace and stability
more than DRC in the wake of the country's long-running war taking 4 million
or more lives causing immeasurable human misery and harm.
All along, the UN was inept, counterproductive and out of the loop. It was
more part of the problem than its solution. It knew all about legal and
illegal arms trading fueling conflict but didn't stop it because its
controlling members did the selling like they always do in war zones
everywhere. In addition, Blue Helmets weren't where most needed and didn't
help when able because direct orders said not to. Kofi Annan was part of the
problem as he was as UN head of peacekeeping in 1994 allowing Rwandans to be
slaughtered when his efforts at least might have ameliorated conditions.
Instead, he kept his mouth shut and head down, refusing to act as he later
did as Secretary-General serving imperial interests he was beholden to. That
meant ignoring desperate people in Congo and all other warring regions.
The DRC is a major one even though things are mostly quieted down - for now.
The country's cursed by being the likely most resource-rich piece of real
estate in the world (except for not having large oil reserves). That makes
it a key target for imperial exploitation and control with Congo's people
suffering just by being there. Sending Blue Helmets to keep peace is just a
fig leaf hiding the dark side of the conflict and who stands to gain with US
interests always topping the list and acting as guarantor nothing interferes
with what Washington has in mind.
So all parties ignore the situation on the ground, and Blue Helmets just
make it worse. The evidence shows UN forces engaged in sex trafficking,
using children as prostitutes. They abused young girls and got away with it
because MONUC officials took no preventive action in spite of pious claims
decrying it. What's common in Congo happens everywhere with so-called
"peacekeepers" acting as thuggish enforcers for imperial powers. Their
mission is "keeping the rabble in line" with free reign to do it harshly as
long as it's kept under wraps. What happens in Congo goes on in Kosovo,
Liberia, Sudan (discussed below) and Haiti also discussed in detail shortly.
It's an ugly story of crackdown, repression or indifference hidden under the
cover of "peacekeeping."
UNMIS in Sudan
UNMIS was established in 2005 to implement the January, 2005 Comprehensive
Peace Treaty between the Sudanese government and Sudan People's Liberation
Movement/Army. It ended the protracted North-South 22 year civil war killing
and uprooting millions in one of the continent's most costly wars, but not
freeing the nation from conflict still ongoing in Darfur. UNMIS has
authority to administer there once hostilities subside, waring sides allow
them entry and agree to cooperate, and Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir
decides if he's willing to risk a regional occupying force hostile to his
interests. Currently a 7,000 force African Union Mission in Sudan (AMIS)
operates in Darfur that's pathetically slim for an area the size of France
in a country the size of Western Europe.
The Sudanese government is justifiably reluctant for Blue Helmets to come
knowing how they behave elsewhere. It also knows what fuels the conflict and
what interests the US and West in the area. Like most everywhere, it's about
valuable resources, and in Darfur it's mainly oil as it is in Somalia where
Washington is involved in another proxy war with US supportive air and
ground involvement this time using an Ethiopian force to be supplemented or
replaced by other regional country contingent "peacekeepers."
The Darfur conflict is falsely portrayed in Western media reports as
atrocities committed by Arab Jan jawid militias supported by the Khartoum
government against black African people. The truth is all parties involved
are indigenous Arabic-speaking black Sunni Muslims involved in intertribal
fighting over increasingly scare water and grazing rights in an area hard
hit by draught and famine. If Blue Helmets come in, they'll make things
worse because they'll be sent for imperial control further harming the
people enduring more than they can already handle.
MINUSTAH in Haiti - Our Main Focus
Since European settlers first arrived in Haiti 500 years ago, this nation
experienced an almost unparalleled legacy of colonial violence and
exploitation. Even when the country gained freedom from France on January 1,
1804, it lay in ruins. Its plantations and sugar works were burned and large
parts of its cities were rubble from many years of conflict. It cost the
nation half its population of former slaves on top of its indigenous
population nearly exterminated by Spanish Conquistadors beginning with the
arrival of Columbus.
Things got no better when Spain kept the Eastern two-thirds of the island in
what's now the Dominican Republic leaving the Western third for French
colonization beginning in the early 1600s. France brought over black African
slaves controlling it till after the 1789 French Revolution that inspired
Haitians to wage theirs for the same freedoms French people got briefly. Led
by Toussaint L'Overture, they prevailed establishing the first free
independent black republic anywhere on their New Years liberation day in
1804.
It was short-lived as France regained control holding it till America took
over later solidifying its regional lock when Woodrow Wilson sent in Marines
in 1915 to protect US investments, doing it in typical US fashion - at the
barrel of a gun. Nineteen years of brutal exploitation followed with
massacres like the kinds seen in Haiti today. The worst of them was in 1929
when US Marines slaughtered 264 protesting peasants in Les Cayes. There were
also smaller incursions, forced labor, and aerial bombing years before the
Nazis' infamous attack on Spain's Republican government at Guernica
supporting opposition fascist dictator, Francisco Franco.
Except for a decade of relief under Jean-Bertand Aristide and Rene Preval,
nothing improved for Haitians after US occupiers left in 1934. Aristide and
Preval brought hope in spite of great Western constraint imposed on them. It
didn't last courtesy of US Marines again ending a brief grace period of
relief and deliverance for people having precious little of it for 500
years.
In its wake, MINUSTAH was established by UN Security Council vote on April
30, 2004 two months after the US-led coup ousted President Aristide now in
forced exile in South Africa. From inception, it's mission was flawed as it
had no right being there in the first place. Blue Helmets, in principle, are
deployed for peace and stability even though they seldom bring it. In this
case, peacekeepers have may been illegally sent for the first time ever
supporting and enforcing a coup d'etat against a democratically elected
president instead of staying out of it or coming to back his right to
office.
The US runs everything in Haiti, and MINUSTAH became its repressive arm
against Haitian people wanting their President back and their freedoms under
him restored. The result is no surprise. MINUSTAH's mission is disastrous,
disgraceful and in violation of the rule of law including UN's own Charter
as explained below.
Before it began, the UN lied claiming Aristide was less than democratically
reelected in 2000 with under 10% of Haitians participating. UN officials
further implied his Fanmi Lavalas party manipulated results allowing him to
win. The truth was otherwise showing Aristide won with a 92% majority and a
turnout of around 62% of eligible voters or a figure exceeding that in most
US elections. The International Foundation for Election Systems (IFES)
suggested turnout was even higher, but mainstream reporting never lets facts
conflict with official US government versions of truth that hide it when it
isn't the kind it wants.
The line on Haiti came from the US State Department's affiliated Agency for
International Development (USAID) claiming the opposition boycotted the
election and Aristide won by default with a low voter turnout. This got
reported as anti-Aristide black propaganda contradicting mass-Haitian
support for a beloved leader twice elected the country's President. Haitians
demand his return but won't get it as long as the US remains in charge.
Washington will ignite a firestorm if he tries coming setting off the kind
of ugliness leading to what happened in February, 2004 that repeated similar
events in September, 1991 after Aristide's first election. The result for
Haitians is nightmarish courtesy of the Bush administration with complicit
Security Council support in the form of Blue Helmet "peacekeepers" enforcing
their kind of peace.
They're on the ground along with mobilized death squads, otherwise known as
the hated Haitian National Police (PNH), acting as a main duel proxy force
serving their masters in Washington. They've done it by destroying all
democratic freedoms in a country subjugated for 500 years under outside
authority or one imposed on them from within. In 1990, Haitians hoped it
ended when they elected Jean-Bertrand Aristide President with 67% of the
vote. He took office in February, 1991, but his tenure was short-lived. It
ended in September by the first of two US-instigated coups removing him from
office for a more compliant military ruler beholden to Washington and its
capital interests.
Aristide returned to Haiti in 1994 regaining nominal power through a deal
Clinton officials arranged. It included a largely US-led UN peacekeeping
force remaining until 1999 to assure political and economic continuity by
IMF-imposed neoliberal structural adjustment policy diktats of
privatizations, debt serving and cuts in vitally needed social services.
Under these conditions and with little financial support when he tried going
around them, Aristide governed like a social democrat compiling an
impressive record given the constraints on him. Under Haitian law, he was
unable to succeed himself in 1996, but his ally Rene Preval ran for
President and won with an 88% majority. Aristide then ran again in 2000
winning big as explained above.
>From then until 2004, Aristide instituted a host of important programs in
>areas of health, education, justice and human rights. He did it by
>maneuvering around the kinds of harsh dictates imposed on him out of
>Washington. It led to his second ouster reinstituting a US-directed reign
>of terror with MINUSTAH Blue Helmet proxies in the lead implementing harsh
>repression still ongoing and unaddressed by a world community mindful of
>conditions but turning a blind eye or playing a supportive role. Blue
>Helmets do this everywhere, but it gets no worse than in Haiti. It's the
>poorest country in the hemisphere, conditions continue getting worse,
>people are suffering, and MINUSTAH is there to keep it that way, not bring
>peace, security, stability or freedom to people desperately needing it.
It's all about the rules of imperial management Washington forces on all
nations but especially ones with strategically important resources, markets
or in the case of Haiti cheap labor. Haiti has lots of it, and it's some of
the cheapest in the world. It's an offshore US manufacturer's paradise where
many garment and other workers earn as little as 12 cents an hour or
near-slave wages. It's far below the poverty level even in Haiti, and after
transportation and other expenses an average Haitian worker earns around $6
a week for those able to get any work in a country plagued by high
unemployment running as high as 50% and at times much higher. During his
tenure, President Aristide alleviated this and much more in spite of great
constraints on him. He did it with scant outside help in spite of
overwhelming pressures from Washington not to do anything affecting capital
interests.
With him gone and reelected President Rene Preval hamstrung under foreign
occupation masquerading as "peacekeepers," Haitians have lost everything.
Conditions have never been worse, and it goes on daily in Haiti's
bloodstained streets patrolled by MINUSTAH, PNH and militarized gangs of
enforcers with license to kill and brutalize freely. The Western media
ignore it in a country the US controls as a de facto colony using violence
for social control just like in Iraq with its own and proxy Iraqi forces.
Guatemalan UN Special Envoy Edmond Mulet calls it needing to "liberate"
neighborhoods from "thugs, criminals, gangs (and) drug dealers." He
characterizes indiscriminate killing of unarmed civilians as "collateral
damage" with UN forces coming "under attack (from gangs in Cite Soleil)."
What he won't address is MINUSTAH'S role as enforcer to make Haiti safe for
predatory capitalism with harsh repression the method of choice to do it.
It's aim is to destroy all vestiges of democratic Lavalas and Jean-Bertrand
Aristide's influence, but it resulted in mass-people resistance on the
streets protesting their plight and demanding restitution of their rights as
free people. Their answer is armed attacks and regular assaults.
It goes on daily with punishing effects against helpless people. They're led
by Blue Helmet thugs attacking Haitians in impoverished areas like Cite
Soleil, Bel Air, Solino and elsewhere indiscriminately killing men, women
and children. They work with PNH enforcers incarcerating or murdering
Aristide supporters and advocates for freedom and justice, forcing many
others underground or to flee the country even after Aristide's Fanmi
Lavalas party was effectively destroyed.
Before Preval's reelection last February, MINUSTAH helped reinstitute
Haiti's brutal and hated former military that Aristide disbanded and put
Haiti again at the mercy of predatory international lending agencies. It
also worked with the so-called Interim Government of Haiti (IGH) under
US-installed puppet prime minister Gerard Latortue ending Aristide's social
programs and returning the country to capital interests with lots of infused
cash ending up in the pockets of the interim government Transparency
International (TI) called the most corrupt in the world, but not enough to
bother its US boss looking the other way and ignoring it. The IGH even
locked up dissenters and emptied prisons of real criminals for service in
the PNH. It also reconstituted Haiti's military and allowed private
paramilitary gangs to operate as brutish enforcers of their own defenseless
people.
It's gone on since the 2004 coup in splendid fashion through bloody street
crackdowns including massacres against people protesting their plight in a
country returned to serfdom under repressive overlords. Haiti is short on
law, order, justice and freedom and long on paramilitary thuggishness
keeping things that way including the private paramilitary ones like the
Little Machete Army that was implicated in the July 6, 2006 Grand Ravine
massacre of more than 20 people along with burning scores of houses in an
act of pure savagery. It was after the August 21, 2005 slaughter in a Grand
Ravine soccer field in front of 5000 fans when as many as 50 people were
shot or hacked to death with machetes by PNH thugs and red-shirted killers.
A recent horrific incident happened in the early morning hours of December
22, 2006 in Cite Soleil when UN Blue Helmets assaulted the community killing
more than 30 people with some reports claiming much higher numbers. It
happened in random mass shooting striking people everywhere including in
their homes with bullets easily penetrating paper-thin walls. The UN claimed
it was after a young man named Belony, supposedly the head of a kidnapping
gang, but the story is pure "baloney" like all other MINUSTAH ones. It's
UN's way to justify repression and killings saying it's targeting bandits
that are really ordinary Haitians protesting their misery or who happen to
be in the line of fire that's deliberately indiscriminate as an added form
of terror.
Disturbingly, President Rene Preval apparently approved the December 22
operation and now has blood on his hands to answer for. He likely knew it's
purpose was to punish an impoverished community that put 10,000 people on
the streets a few days earlier demonstrating for the return of Jean-Bertrand
Aristide and condemning a US-directed militarized occupation of their
country. Video footage and eye witnesses captured and verified the
retaliatory response on the streets with unarmed civilians shot by random
gunfire including from helicopter gunships. At first the UN denied it but
finally admitted what video footage and digital photos showed conclusively.
They also showed wounded and dying with no medical help on the scene and
people left to bleed to death on the streets or in their homes.
This assault was like an earlier one against Cite Soleil on July 6, 2005
when UN forces attacked the city with hundreds of heavily armed troops using
M-50s and 60s mounted on armored personnel vehicles. It also used
high-powered telescopic rifles for accuracy in singling out targeted
dissenters for assassination and a type of gattling gun firing
armor-piercing bullets believed to be depleted uranium tipped to slice
through metal like butter. This time about 70 people were shot
indiscriminately from thousands of rounds of ammunition fired. Again those
hit were left to bleed to death unattended on the streets or in their homes.
A more recent documented incident happened in Cite Soleil on January 23,
2007 with MINUSTAH forces again randomly shooting for hours including from
helicopters while people ran for their lives or were gunned down
indiscriminately as they did. No accurate count of casualties is known so
far, and the number killed may never be known as Blue Helmets often remove
bodies to conceal the extent of their handiwork. Another attack followed on
January 24 with MINUSTAH acknowledging it killed six people and wounded
others in the same targeted community. Haitians won't ever be free of this
until peacekeepers leave, Blue Helmet terrorism ends and people can choose
their own leaders, free from outside control, or not live under ones imposed
on them.
For now, that seems light years away, and all reports out of Haiti are grim
including a January 23 one by the National Bishops' Justice and Peace
Commission (JILAP), a human rights commission of Haiti's Roman Catholic
church. It reported at least 539 people died violently in Port-au-Prince
alone in the three month period ending December 31, 2006 with the true
number likely higher as it only counted dead bodies on the streets. Most of
the victims were in impoverished communities like Cite Soleil, Grand Ravine,
Martissant and Bolosse, and the main cause of death was from gunshot wounds.
JILAP also attributed most of the violence to MINUSTAH and PNH with most
deaths just local residents in targeted areas. Other violence was blamed on
street gangs like the one led by the Little Machete Army that may have
murdered Haitian independent journalist Jean Remy Badiau in Martissant
because he "dared practice journalism in a country where the press (today)
is never free."
Sadly, Haitians have no freedom because the extent of occupation-led terror
is greater than Haiti's ever had in its 200 year history as a sovereign
state. It amounts to collective punishment of an impoverished people living
under US-imposed police state type daily killings, massacres, rapes,
arbitrary arrests, mass incarcerations, beatings and horrific immiseration
of millions of people defenseless against it. It also includes human
trafficking of women and children for forced prostitution and men and women
for forced labor amounting to chattel slavery. Additional thousands of men
have been forcibly taken to the Dominican Republic and other regional
countries to work for wages so low they're called "sugar slaves."
Still more abuse came out in the September, 2006 Lancet reported study
conducted by Wayne State University, School of Social Work researchers
Athena Kolbe and Dr. Royce Hutson. They exposed and documented massive human
rights violations in Haiti under the puppet Latortue government using random
Global Positioning System (GPS) coordinate sampling of 1260 households and
5720 individuals. 90.7% of them were interviewed using a structured
questionnaire by trained interviewers to learn about their experiences since
Aristide's ouster.
The study findings estimated 8,000 people were murdered and about 35,000
women (over half under 18)sexually assaulted in the greater Port-au-Prince
area between February, 2004 and December, 2005. 21% of killings were
attributed to the PNH, 13% to the demobilized army and another 13% to
anti-Aristide paramilitary gangs like the Little Machete Army. Known
criminals were the worst sex offenders, but officers from the HNP accounted
for 13.8% of assaults and armed anti-Lavalas groups another 10.6%. The
report also documented kidnappings, extrajudicial detentions, physical
assaults other than rape, death threats, physical threats and threats of
sexual violence against helpless people.
The report concluded that "crime and systematic abuse of human rights were
common in Port-au-Prince" involving criminals but also "political actors and
UN (Blue Helmet) soldiers." It also stressed an overwhelming need on the
ground for attention to "legal, medical, psychological, and economic
consequences of widespread human rights abuses and crime."
The study ended in December, 2005, but the same abuses go on daily in
Haitian communities around Port-au-Prince and elsewhere in the country. It's
a picture of UN failure and its top officials and Secretary-General
corrupted and criminally complicit with its authorized missions' worst
crimes and abuses going on everywhere. It also shows the world body as a
servant of power, defiling its founding mandate and damning the poor and
weak to pay for its failure to protect them. Nowhere are things worse than
in Haiti, and nowhere are UN representatives more culpable starting at the
top where the buck stops with its former Secretary-General Kofi Annan. His
tenure ended in December as it began - in disgrace but whose record went
unreported because he served power interests well who'll now reward him in
his new endeavors.
Haitians hoped things might not be this way last February 7 when they
reelected Rene Preval their President in an electoral process orchestrated,
controlled and rigged by the US-installed puppet government but not enough
to override the will of the people. For the first time in two years,
desperate Haitians had reason to celebrate with a leader again in charge who
once served their needs as President. But nothing is ever simple in Haiti,
and long knives in Washington were out to undermine and destabilize Preval's
rule from its outset or simply work around him and ignore it. The result to
date is capital rules the country, and Rene Preval has little to show for
his first year in office. Haitians continue suffering, and 9,000 repressive
Blue Helmets, PNH and other paramilitaries are on the ground keeping it that
way.
It affects the lives of helpless people in ways beyond brute force and
economic depravation. Blue Helmet attacks in Cite Soleil severely damaged
the community's public water system as random gunfire hit pipelines and a
water tower. It forced area residents to walk long distances with heavy
buckets for what's unavailable close by while private speculators truck in
drinking water for sale at prices Cite Soleil's half million residents can't
afford. It's one more part of marketplace rule leaving most Haitians out of
it with no resources to participate.
The UN peacekeeping mandate expires on February 15, but Haitians won't see
the end of it. The Security Council is about to extend the mission with
disagreement over its length that comes up for review every six months.
Before leaving office, Kofi Annan recommended a year's extension, but
unanimity hasn't yet been reached by Security Council members. When it is,
it won't reflect the peoples' will demanding Blue Helmets leave that's
loudly heard on the streets and ignored as it always is.
Protests and demonstrations are on the capital's streets all the time, but a
major one happened on February 7 as well as in six other Haitian cities and
many around the world in solidarity. They dramatically dispelled the UN's
false assertions that Lavalas is dead. It lives, it's vibrant, and it puts a
lie to UN Envoy Edmond Mulet's claim that "the issue of former President
Aristide is not present anymore....in Haiti....and his (Fanmi Lavalas)
movement is very much divided, weakened."
The date marked the 16th anniversary of Jean-Bertrand Aristide's first
inauguration as Haiti's first elected President in 1991 and 21st anniversary
of the end of the hated Duvalier father-son dictatorship in 1986. Tens of
thousands of Fanmi Lavalas supporters took to the streets peacefully to
protest their occupation and violence from it. They called for the release
of all political prisoners and demanded return of those in forced exile
starting with their former President deposed on February 29, 2004.
Protestors joined with them in solidarity in 53 cities around the world on
five continents against Blue Helmet massacres in an "International Day in
Solidarity with the Haitian People." On the same day, protesters went to
Haiti's UN heavily guarded Port-au-Prince military headquarters demanding
Aristide's return and confronting soldiers with shouts of "Down with the
UN." Hundreds were back the following day repeating their chants and risking
the kind of retaliation they've come to expect before.
They got their answer on February 9 when hundreds of UN peacekeepers again
raided Cite Soleil before dawn continuing their ritualized crackdown and
retaliation against courageous people resistance. It's made Blue Helmets a
hated symbol of imperial repression and all the terror from it. For Haitian
people, it's just the latest chapter in their 500 year struggle never losing
hope one day they'll be free at last. No people deserve it more than do
Haitians.
Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at
lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net [1].
Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com [2] and tune in online to
hear The Steve Lendman News and Information Hour on TheMicroEffect.com [3]
each Saturday at noon US central time.
_______
--
NOTICE: This post contains copyrighted material the use of which has not
always been authorized by the copyright owner. I am making such material
available to advance understanding of
political, human rights, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues. I
believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material as
provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107
"A little patience and we shall see the reign of witches pass over, their
spells dissolve, and the people recovering their true sight, restore their
government to its true principles. It is true that in the meantime we are
suffering deeply in spirit,
and incurring the horrors of a war and long oppressions of enormous public
debt. But if the game runs sometimes against us at home we must have
patience till luck turns, and then we shall have an opportunity of winning
back the principles we have lost, for this is a game where principles are at
stake."
-Thomas Jefferson