Which one's better?

Status
Not open for further replies.

LPNailz

New member
Yeah...so, wierd question, but which of these paragraphs do you like better? Please take the time to read and comment, I'd really appreciate it, thanks. :thumbsup:

The first version…

Running through the streets, someone chasing her. Someone with a knife, or a gun, or a rope. Only a little girl, with a little boy by her side, running as fast as they can, but what if they can’t run fast enough? And his tiny hand slips from hers, because he’s stopped running. She turns to scream his name, the name she can’t remember now, and she sees their pursuer standing over him, lunging down with a shining blade, his crazed eyes glinting in the moonlight, foam around his mouth. But the little boy is calm, and while the man is coming down, he is moving to the side, his small hand rising to somehow catch the knife out of the man’s hand; and with a seemingly practiced motion he stabs the man in the back of the head. Then he turns to the girl, eyes black and somewhere between unknowingly innocent and expecting praise. His hand is still on the knife’s handle, and the girl cannot breathe. She is alive, he is alive…but he has killed. He has done the very thing she feared would happen to him. She begins backing away from him, from his tiny, bony body, and he, confused, comes towards her.

She screams and runs from him…

_______________________________________________________________________

The second version…

Running through the dark streets, someone chasing me…someone with a knife, or a gun, or a rope...

Only a little girl, with a little boy at her side, running as fast as they can. And what If they can’t run fast enough? She clenches his tiny hand as tight as she can, but it slips from hers…because he’s stopped running.

She turns to scream his name, the name she can’t remember now, and sees their pursuer standing over him, lunging down with a shining blade, crazed eyes glinting in the moonlight and foam around his mouth. But the little boy is calm, and as his attacker is coming down, he is moving to the side, and he somehow catches the knife out of the man’s hand. With a spine-chillingly practiced motion, he stabs the man in the back of the head; he falls to the ground and moves no more.

The little boy turns to the girl, his expression somewhere between unknowingly innocent and expecting praise. His tiny hand is still on the knife’s handle, and she cannot breathe. All should be well…he is alive, she is alive, but he has killed. He has done the very thing she feared would happen to him. He has become what she fears. She steps backward, away from him, in terror. Hurt, a little confused, he comes towards her.

She screams and runs from him…

 

Ravynlee

New member
I prefer the second. Because there is a lot of drama or angst in this you sort of need time to digest it, which is where the second layout works better. Maybe it was me, I didn't notice a great deal of deviation (aside from POV) between them in terms of content, but again, if you are writing something that is intentionally fast paced, that you want to sort of sweep the reader in and carry them away in a kind of literary whirlwind you can stick with number one.

Me, I prefer number 2. I like those 'drawing breath' pauses between paragraphs. Also serves to help me absorb and remember what I just read, rather than getting hit all at once and getting to the end and going... huh?

Just my opinion. Hope it makes sense :)

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom