Evanescence VS Lacuna Coil VS Nightwish VS Arch Enemy

[woodyloveslinkin]

Yes I am making you all choose.

 

Okay here's my love of Evanescence:

> Bring Me To Life

> Haunted

> Breathe No More

> Snow White Queen

> The Only One

> THe Last Song I'm Wasting On You

 

Here's my love of Lacuna Coil:

> Closer

> Devoted

> Our Truth

> Unspoken

> To The Edge

> Within Me

 

Here's my love of Nightwish:

> Wish I Had an Angel

> Angels Fall First

> Romanticide

> Eva

> Nemo

> Planet Hell

> Wishmaster <33333 I'm currently addicted to that song

> For the Heart I Once Had

 

So in order:

1 Evanescence (only cos I've been listening to them longer than Nightwish)

2 Nightwish

3 Lacuna Coil

 

I'm sorry but I cannot get into Arch Enemy at all.

[Linkin_lp_park]

Of those 4 I only really listen to Evanescence

 

I love Fallen

And I like some of the songs of The Open Door

[Jeezy]

Honestly...I don't really listen to any of them...

 

But I would pick Evanescence..Just because they have some good songs that I know

[Stenners]

Lacuna Coil.... because they have a handful of decent (not great) songs, where as the others.....

[littleblackstone]

the only band I really like of these ones is Arch Enemy.

I really like vocalist's voice!! \m/

[Friðbjörn]

I don't know any of these bands deeply, but my choice is at least definitely not evanescence

[untitled]

evanescence, it's the only one i listened to of these for lol

[littleblackstone]

actually i got sick of evanescence...

 

that amy lee :-! lol

[Linkin_lp_park]

actually i got sick of evanescence...

 

that amy lee :-! lol

 

SHE`S HOT ..

[Jeezy]

SHE`S HOT ..

 

oh yeah...she should be a teacher....lmao

[Linkin_lp_park]

oh yeah...she should be a teacher....lmao

 

I wouldn´t mind detention at all

[GraDoN]

haha nae she aint my type. to me she looks like those "im hot with make up and the right camera angle" girls, if you know what i mean -_-

[Jeezy]

haha nae she aint my type. to me she looks like those "im hot with make up and the right camera angle" girls, if you know what i mean -_-

 

yeah like Avril...

 

but seriously...we got off topic right now

[LPShinodaFM]

I only listen to Evanescence from the four... so meh

 

^I see what you're saying, and I do think that she is hot with makeup and stuff... with a nongay status... and that without makeup she's just like another person you see on the street. But I like her voice, I guess...

[GraDoN]

well none of them really... but from that i would have to go with Evenesense hehe i never really know how to spell their name :>

[Linkin_lp_park]

well none of them really... but from that i would have to go with Evenesense hehe i never really know how to spell their name :>

 

Just look at the poll haha

[stupidsoul1]

I voted lacuna coil.

Their music is pretty well made,especially cristinas vocals.

i think they would put on an amazing live performance, so gutted i don't get to see them.

 

But i saw arch enemy the other night at the black crusade..angela was amazing.

my boyfriend and i love the way that she can scream with such force.

 

 

I wouldn't pay to go see evanescence especially since amy lee lip synch's some of the songs.

 

Nightwish is great sometimes, the new singer is good because sometimes i would get sick of the old singers voice.

[xXMelancholiaXx]

None of these bands really have anything in common except for the fact that they all have female vocalists. You can't really compare them either since they are all in different genres. The only two that seem vaguely fair to compare would be Lacuna Coil if you only look at their new stuff and Evanescence. The rest don't fit.

[Friðbjörn]

yeah you could've added some band like guano apes or the cardigans to this poll just whatever

[Stllmn8j]

I'll take Lacuna Coil because they've had a couple decent songs compared to the other 2

[Mikes_Shadow]

it's impossible to compare arch enemy to bands like nightwish, lacuna coil and evanescence is silly.

they're a completely different genre.

 

but I voted nightwish merely because of my mass love of them.

[Rock 89]

Nightwish, Nightwish, and again Nightwish.

It's a band with great musicians and powerful voices. It's my favourite gothic metal group (evanescence and new stuff of lacuna coil are gothic rock, sometimes very commercial)

The bad thing is that Tarja Turunen (the singer) left the group in 2005 and now they have a new singer, and this influenced the band's sound in negative...

Well, I don't know Arch Enemy, so I can't talk of they...

[xXMelancholiaXx]

it's impossible to compare arch enemy to bands like nightwish, lacuna coil and evanescence is silly.

they're a completely different genre.

 

but I voted nightwish merely because of my mass love of them.

You said everything that I feel. <3

 

The next poll will probably be comparing KoRn to Sonata Arctica or something...:lol:

[woodyloveslinkin]

Nightwish, Nightwish, and again Nightwish.

It's a band with great musicians and powerful voices. It's my favourite gothic metal group (evanescence and new stuff of lacuna coil are gothic rock, sometimes very commercial)

The bad thing is that Tarja Turunen (the singer) left the group in 2005 and now they have a new singer, and this influenced the band's sound in negative...

Well, I don't know Arch Enemy, so I can't talk of they...

 

Anette is Amy Lee all the way.

Tarja <3333333

Anette is just whiney voiced which defeats the whole purpose of Nightwish's symphonic side.

 

Gemma - Well I just did. Because they all have one thing in common, all leads are females.

[Rock 89]

Anette is Amy Lee all the way.

Tarja <3333333

Anette is just whiney voiced which defeats the whole purpose of Nightwish's symphonic side.

 

That's right! I rewant Tarja!

Then I want to write in that Nightwish are great in live! (you can see them in End of an Era dvd)

Evanescence... Amy goes out of breath frequently, and instruments become louder than her voice.